Posts in Current Events
Financial Advising Through a Crisis
 

After starting my career as a financial advisor in the mid-'90s, I learned pretty quickly how crucial wise counsel could be in times of crisis.  About this time 20 years ago, the "dot-com" bubble burst sending the Nasdaq Composite stock index down nearly 80%.  Around that same time, September 11, 2001, happened, which changed cockpits on planes and screening at airports forever.  In the days after September 11, we waited anxiously for the markets to re-open (which they finally did the following Monday.)  Finally, I rode shotgun with the rest of the world through the financial crisis, which took the markets down over 50%, with some industries getting hit much harder than others. 

What I learned during these times of crisis, is to take a levelheaded "barbell" approach to manage decisions for clients, my company, and my family.  So, what does a "barbell" approach look like?  On one end of the barbell, is your job, your checking and savings account.  On the other end of the barbell is life back to normal and managing long term accounts such as college savings and retirement.

Examples of Advice we are Sharing with Clients

As an example, we work for a family whose breadwinner is a surgeon.  They have six months of savings in their checking account, but virtually no income planned from work for the next six months.  So, what do we recommend?  For them, we will raise enough cash to get them through the year with all bills paid, and a lifestyle they are accustomed to living. They are going to delay making college savings payments with a plan to catch-up later. They are also going to delay making any non-critical purchases until the dust settles on the current pandemic.  We are not recommending making any changes to their accounts outside shoring up their short term cash reserves because their job and income have changed—as such, raising cash is a necessary step. 

In another example, I spoke with a client in underground construction.  His wife is in the medical profession.  He sees his income staying the same as there is a need for their work regardless of external circumstances. On the flip side, her salary is in question for the next six months.  So, what are they doing and what are we recommending? First, because they are nearing retirement, half of their portfolio has been in bonds and cash.  They have six months of cash-on-hand and another decade worth of safe investments.  Their short- and medium-term cash needs are taken care of, so now we are looking at the question of retirement. For now, doing retirement planning does not make sense, given we are unclear as to how long the current financial crisis will be at play.  What we do know is that we will have much better information six months or even a year from now, and at that point, planning for the long term will make sense once again.

Lessons learned from past crisis management

The best advice we can offer right now is to make sure you take a barbell approach to manage your financial affairs.  The only short term market-related decisions we are recommending are ones that take care of creating a buffer to supplement disruptions in cashflow and job-related income.  If you need to raise cash, think about how much you spend monthly, and cover yourself for a year.  If, on the other hand, your job is stable, and cash on hand is plentiful, do not touch your accounts, sit tight, be thankful for the position you are in right now. 

As new information comes out about COVID-19, we will be offering our advice and counsel through our blog here.  We have a great team of certified financial planners, CPAs, and other subject matter experts that are actively posting financial guidance and recommendations for Human Investing clients—of which we are happy to share with the public in these challenging times.    

 

 
 

Related Articles

My Personal Three C’s Of The Week: Controllables, Crisis, Charity
 

My older daughter Norah (2) speaks part English part “Daniel The Tiger”. Walking around our house she will randomly shout statements like, “ I don’t meow, have to meow” (we are obviously doing great as parents) or something easier on the ears like, “I love you just the way you are Daddy”.

The volatility we are seeing in the markets, as it relates to day to day swings, has not been seen since the late 1920s. Between the volatility, we are seeing in the markets and the effects of the Coronavirus socially and on local businesses, it seems like we are in for quite a ride. Today I found myself humming a timely Daniel The Tiger tune. Ultimately reminding myself to control the controllables and relax.

“Give a squeeze, nice and slow. Take a deep breath, let it go”

3 c's chart A.png

Whether you are working from home right now, finishing up at your place of work or are now forced into a home school teaching role, we all have a lot of thoughts going. Here’s how I’m processing mine:

Controllables:

This can apply to how we interact with others in the world however, I’m applying it to investing. As of the close today, the S&P is down 30% off its highs with individual companies we are all familiar with down much farther.

3c's chart.png

At our firm, we have strict rules and guidelines around rebalancing. After reading others’ research and conducting our own, rebalancing based on time (semi-annually, annually, etc.) and threshold (if a position becomes underweight or overweight compared to the rest of the portfolio) can greatly improve the risk/return characteristics of an investment strategy. It also incorporates a “buy low” “sell high” attitude and can feel like you are taking action in volatile markets while not succumbing to market timing.  Note that the use of an Investment Policy or a rebalancing policy is a must.

Lastly, rebalancing isn’t solely about buying low and selling high. Another key feature is managing your risk over long periods of time, especially if you are taking withdrawals. Michael Kitces has done multiple posts about this. The below chart tracked withdrawals over a 30 year period. You can see how during down markets the lack of rebalancing diminishes the portfolio.

Chart_WithWithoutRebal_ver3.jpg

Crisis:

A timely podcast from Patrick O’Shaunghnessy came out this week titled “Investing Through Crisis”. I wanted to be careful before using the word “crisis” in this post, but the definition seems to fit the times. The paper, written by the Dan Rasmussen the interviewee of Verdad Capital, was published in the Winter of 2019 and looks back on past periods of crisis and if there were any silver linings that could be taken from it. Here are some bullet points that I think we can help us today:

  • There is the expansion of the breadth of rational beliefs during times like this: Rasmussen goes on to point out that there is massive uncertainty around the worst-case scenarios and best scenarios and often the world can’t disprove either. This is a key metric in volatile markets.

  • Bear markets have more predictable movements than Bull markets: Human behavior (fear, worry, etc.) drive bear markets. What’s worked (the rationale behind a bull market) will vary case by case.

  • Market timing requires three unknown data points: Being correct on all three of the below data points is highly unlikely. 

    • You must decide what’s going to happen in the future

    • You must decide when to get out

    • You must decide when to get in

Charity:

I read this post that inspired me to take a step back and be grateful for what I have as opposed to what is uncertain. In Portland there are/will be many groups specifically impacted by the Coronavirus. After talking with a few local leaders, they substantiated that donating to these causes can have a profound impact:

-          Oregon Community Foundation

-          Oregon Food Bank

-          Meals on Wheels

-          American Red Cross

 

 
 

Related Articles

We All Have Choices To Make
 
@soymeraki

@soymeraki

I was asked this week, "How do you make sense of how or why the market is responding the way it is?"

When something such as COVID-19 disrupts trade and travel there is less economic activity.

When there is less economic activity there are less future earnings.

When there are less future earnings there are lower stock prices.

When there are lower stock prices an investor’s account values decrease.

When an investor’s account values decrease, investors have a choice to make.

The choice to buy, sell or hold can be an incredibly difficult one to make. This is especially true when:

  • There are more zeros at the end of one's account balance.

  • An investor with a short time horizon and a need to access funds from their accounts.

  • Someone worked hard to build their account balance up to $10k and now it is worth $7.4k.

The type of investor we are is determined by the decisions that we make, especially considering our current market situation. As the esteemed American Neurologist and financial author William Bernstein puts it there are three groups of investors:

Group 1: The average small investor, who does not have a coherent asset-allocation strategy and who owns a chaotic mix of mutual funds and/or individual securities, often recommended to him or her by a broker or advisor. He or she tends to buy near bull market peaks and sell near bear market troughs.

Group 2: The more sophisticated investor, who does have a reasonable-seeming asset-allocation strategy and who will buy when prices fall a bit (“buying the dips”), but who falls victim to the aircraft simulator/actual crash paradigm, loses his or her nerve, and bails when real trouble roils the markets. You may not think you belong in this group, but unless you’ve tested yourself and passed during the 2008–2009 bear market, you really can’t tell.

Group 3: Those who do have a coherent strategy and can stick to it. Three things separate this group from Group 2: first, a realistic appraisal of their true, under-fire risk tolerance; second, an allocation to risky assets low enough, or a savings rate high enough, to allow them to financially and emotionally weather a severe downturn; and third, an appreciation of market history, particularly the carnage inflicted by the 1929–1932 bear market. In other words, this elite group possesses not only patience, cash, and courage, but also the historical knowledge informing them that at several points in their investing career, all three will prove necessary. Finally, they have the foresight to plan for those eventualities.

For most who fall into Group 1 & 2, it is not the intention that prevents someone from landing in Group 3 but rather a lack of planning and/or perspective. Having perspective can make it easier to make wise decisions, especially in the midst of chaos. I don't wish to diminish what we are experiencing with "don’t worry its all going to be ok." However, as we think about COVID-19 in historical context it's hard not to witness the ongoing resiliency of mankind and our economical system. See below for how the markets have weathered the last several years (1/1/08 - 12/31/19).

Source: First Trust Advisors L.P.

Source: First Trust Advisors L.P.

There is more to be said about resiliency when we scale back to 1900. (see below)

Source: FactSet, NBER, Robert Shiller, J.P. Morgan Asset Management.

Source: FactSet, NBER, Robert Shiller, J.P. Morgan Asset Management.

The reality is that whether your retirement timeline is near or far, most of us will be impacted in one way or another by COVID-19 and COVID-19’s impact on our global economy. We all have choices to make. If you are making decisions to protect your health look to CDC for guidance. If you are making decisions with regards to your investments, gain some perspective and talk to your financial advisor. Let us know how we can help, contact us at Human Investing or call at 503.905.3100.

“Job one for the investor, then, is to learn as best she can, to ignore the day-to-day and year-to-year speculative return in order to earn the fundamental return.” – William Bernstein

SOURCES:

Rational Expectations: Asset Allocation for Investing Adults by William Bernstein.

 

 
 

Related Articles

The Last 72 Hours - What's Changed & What's Stayed The Same
 

On Monday I wrote this blog post sharing our firm's thoughts on the current state of market volatility. If you haven’t read the blog I’d highly encourage you to do so. Candidly, writing that feels like 3 months ago as opposed to 3 days ago.

What’s Changed:

  • WHO declares Coronavirus a pandemic

  • President Trump declares a travel ban in the EU

  • Many Sporting Events are canceled or postponed

  • For Oregonian’s, Governor Brown cancels events over 250 people

  • Universities and School Districts go online or close for periods of time

  • A well-known celebrity, Tom Hanks tests positive for Coronavirus

  • Lastly, the stock market has gone from being 18% off its highs on Monday to 26% off its highs as of the market close today (Thursday, March 12th). Along the way, it suffered it’s worst single-day loss since 1987.

High.jpg

When speaking with a co-worker Wednesday night it seemed like there was a social tipping point for many Americans regarding the potential seriousness of the virus. It felt closer. Add in what’s happening with the price of oil and interest rates and you get the fastest move from a market high to being in a “bear market”.

bear.jpg

What’s Stayed The Same:

A quote I’ve been thinking about this week is, “There’s an art to taking action and an art to justifying inaction”. Another piece of information that was shared today in our office was “In volatile times like this its necessary to be more disciplined not less discipline.” The same principles still apply to being a great investor today as they did a month ago. It’s simply harder to execute when chaos is occurring around us.

As hard as is it is, most likely inaction is the best course during times of increased volatility. It’s common for some of the best days of the market to be close in close proximity to some of the worst. Here’s what happens when you miss out on some of those days.

Missing.JPG

Going to cash and getting back in when it feels better is harder than it sounds. This quote from Josh Brown a CNBC pundit and CEO of Ritholtz Wealth Management provided this perspective from March of 2009 (the bottom of the financial crisis) and what it looked like to get back in:

The great answer is that you won’t know when the dust settles. There’s no airplane writing the “all clear” in the sky above your neighborhood. And when the dust settles, do you think stocks will be at their lows? Or will they have already rallied furiously, in anticipation of this? Let me give you an example. Imagine it’s March 9th. About eleven years ago, in 2009, the stock market stopped going down. There was no reason. The dust had settled, without fanfare or any sort of official announcement. If you had polled people that day, or week or even month, most would not have agreed that we had seen the worst. The economic headlines were not improving. But there it was. And by June 12th, about 3 months later, the stock market had climbed 40% from that March low. And even with that having happened, the majority of investors still weren’t clear that the dust had fully settled.“

Market.JPG

Do you what you need to do to make it through times of increased volatility in the market. I heard the term “social distancing yourself from your 401(k)” and it provided a much-needed laugh. Having discipline and staying the course on your plan is much easier when you have a plan. Whether it’s using your own tools or entrusting a fiduciary to partner with you, knowing that you did the planning work upfront makes all the difference in when 3 days feels like 3 months.

 

 
 

Related Articles

Market Volatility - The Cost of Admission
 
Buffett.jpg

I read two bite-size pieces of content last week that equally affected me:

“The whole reason stocks tend to do well over time is because they make you put up with stuff like this. It’s the cost of admission. A feature, not a bug” – Morgan Housel Collaborative Fund

“Telling people to ignore the noise is telling people not to be people” – Michael Batnick Ritholtz Wealth Management

As an advisor to families, endowments and corporate retirement plans our firm lives in the tension of these types of statements often. The ability to substantiate recommendations with facts, as opposed to noise, while recognizing each client that we work with has a unique set of circumstances hopefully validates our name Human Investing.

Our team (probably like you) is learning, reading and writing about the set of current events.  Like Housel and Batnick mention, it’s a combination of having perspective (in other words we’ve been here before) and recognizing that each time the market flirts with “correction” territory it’s a reasonable behavior to feel uncertainty.  We find the charts, statements, and questions listed below helpful when talking to clients and hope you do as well.

For most people, this is a price of admission scenario:

Today was the 17th worst day for the S&P 500.  Since 1825 the US Stock Market has returned nearly 10% per year. The below histogram does an excellent job of showing how those returns are plotted over the last 195 years. Like we mentioned above, investors do not receive excellent returns without taking on risk. Days like today are the price of admission.

histogram.png

“But this time it’s different”

You’re right this time it is different due to the speed of the market declining and the intersection of COVID-19, oil prices steeply declining and the federal reserve lowering interest rates. Not to be dismissive of the current world events, but it’s different every time. It was different during the dot com bubble and the 2008 financial crisis as well. These visuals help provide perspective regarding the current volatility we are seeing and what’s normal.

A.  Drawdowns in the market happen all the time. This current drawdown is around 18% (so far) which is slightly below the normal intra-year drawdown of nearly 14% since 1980.

percent off high.jpg
Vol is normal.jpg

B. These charts show that while the speed of this drawdown is occurring faster than normal. The fact that we are experiencing volatility linked to world events occurs more often than we might initially think.

quick down.jpg
world events.jpg

“Buying into this market seems terrifying should I go to cash (or stay in cash if applicable)?”

Two scenarios come to mind:

A.  You’re fully invested right now: Market timing is rarely (most likely never) a good idea. This is where knowing yourself as an investor and the qualitative side of the equation matters as much as the data. If slightly reducing how aggressive you are will allow you to sleep at night and not press the “sell all” button then consider strategies along those lines that lead to better long term outcomes. Otherwise, stay the course.

B. You’re in cash right now and waiting for an entry point: Consider this scenario. Over the last 20 years, the worst day to invest in the S&P 500 was April 7th, 2000. As the chart below shows $10k invested then is worth around $27k today. However, it took until December of 2013 (over 13 years!) for the $10k to be made whole on the initial investment and never look back. It’s a good case study for the recent worst-case scenario of investing in stocks and more specifically investing a lump sum of cash.

Capture.PNG

What’s tomorrow, this next week, this next month have in store for investors? Carl Richards said it best, “Are you concerned about days or decades?” Investing calls for a long term approach. Let’s take a page out of Warren Buffet’s book and get back at it tomorrow.

Be fearful when others are greedy and greedy when others are fearful
— Warren Buffett
 

 
 

Related Articles

Addressing the Fear du Jour
 
@derstudi

@derstudi

The fear du jour is COVID-19, also known as the Coronavirus.  Each of us has a lot to be concerned about, particularly given the uncertainty of epidemics and even pandemics—couple this with volumes of misinformation and fear stoked by the media. Outbreaks of infectious diseases have consistently occurred over the past century; names like Spanish Flu, Asian Flu, Hong Kong Flu, SARS, Swine Flu, Ebola, Zika, and Dengue are just a few. Although unnerving and cause for concern, we are still here today functioning, producing, consuming, and living life. 

For the investment community, the concern is less about the loss of life and more about productivity, consumer spending, and growth. With consumer spending in the U.S. making up approximately 70% of GDP, the concerns of an economic slowdown are valid. Important for market participants is the material impact of the slowdown due to a lack of spending.  At the same time, furloughed workers and canceled events may harm a company’s ability to make money. Regardless of the situation, company earnings may potentially go down due to the widespread impact of COVID-19—and with it, their stock price often follows. 

YOUR FINANCIAL PLAN PREPARES YOU FOR THE UNEXPECTED

It is important to note that these are the current events; we are just reporting the news as we know it today. A financial plan, constructed by a Certified Financial Planning Professional or CFP®, considers the market impact of pandemics, wars, natural disasters, and the like. These situations, although not explicitly named in the financial planning calculations, are implied in the battery of historical market performance tests (called Monte Carlo Simulations). As such, those with a plan (investment, retirement, etc.) should stick to the plan. Now is not the time to go and make drastic changes. As one Human Investing client put it, “Now is when everyone needs a plan and partners they trust to achieve it.”

The worst days of the market may be ahead. Alternatively, the market could bounce tomorrow and be back on track for another stellar year. This is why during volatile times we look to the thoughtfully developed plans we created alongside our clients. In times such as these, we are grateful for each of our clients who have placed their trust in our firm over the last 15 years, and we look forward to connecting with you soon.

Sincerely,

Peter Fisher

 

 
 

Related Articles

What Does an Economic Slowdown Mean for the Market?
 
40456713_487599518382906_6073647940115622971_n.jpg

In my last post, I wrote about the positive impact of financial planning on an investor's ability to stay in the market and manage the cognitive bias of loss aversion. In this post, I want to address recessions, market performance, and the cognitive bias of "recency." Recency bias occurs when an individual is more inclined to remember something that happened more recently than what may be recognized years before, creating a bias.

Economic Slowdowns and the Market

Several times in the last few days I have heard a stock market prognosticator suggest an economic slowdown is upon us. So, what is a slowdown or “recession”? Technically speaking, a recession is two consecutive negative quarters of GDP growth. Importantly, recessions are not uncommon and do not necessarily coincide with a decrease in the stock market.

While examining the chart below, the first column highlights the last nine recessions. The next five columns track the corresponding stock market performance for one year before the recession, the stock market return for the length of the recession, along with one, three, and five-year performance following the recession. In my view, the data is quite interesting and full of surprises.

recession-performance.png

Recency Bias

Recency bias, as mentioned above, clouds an investor’s understanding of complete market data. As such, with the last two most recent recessions having had a negative 35.5% and 7.2% respectively, investors are more likely to believe all recessions have comparably negative returns—this is in fact not true. 

Although recessions and market volatility are unnerving, it is both normal and part of the price we pay for the opportunity to achieve fantastic long-term returns. We encourage you to focus on the financial plan which offers investors the best odds of achieving financial success.    

 

 
 

Related Articles

Is Your "Uncle Larry" Giving You The Best Investment Advice?
 

I’ve done it with a construction project at my house and maybe you’ve done it with your retirement account. Yes, I’m talking about going to Uncle Larry, the person who is never short on advice but not necessarily an expert. For those of you who aren’t tracking, “Uncle Larry” is a figurative yet all too real figure who is willing to give out advice about most anything, and we tend to eat it up. Even though Uncle Larry is a tongue-in-cheek character, the reality is I’ve seen the damage he or she has done to retirement accounts. I get it, finding sound unbiased advice isn’t easy and the deck can be stacked against investors when it comes to receiving it. The good news is there’s hope. While we can't always run away from unsolicited advice, we can be equipped with some perspective and good questions to ask. My hope is to provide an outline with some good questions and standards when it comes to receiving advice, regardless of whether it’s from a family member or professional.

What’s your track record?

  • This question might be a little awkward if you’re asking your sister-in-law at the Thanksgiving table, but it is a reasonable one if she is offering advice on your retirement plan.

  • Don’t be afraid to get specific! If it’s an advisor, ask for references. If it’s a family member, ask for last year’s statement!

What’s your process for a recommendation?

  • If all your older brother is doing is simply looking at what fund has performed best for the last 3 months, odds are you aren’t going to be in a good situation. Instead, looking at the funds expense ratio, or cost structure of the fund can be a great resource. The lower the expense ratio (relative to the asset class) the better the predictor of returns.

Is there a conflict of interest?

  • This question is more specific to the cousin who works as a stock broker. If the name of the company she works for is the same as the name on the mutual funds in your account, that’s probably not a good sign. Imagine if Pizza Hut was the judge of the country’s best pizza; that’s like asking for the best fund from someone who is compensated by the recommendation they are making!

So what do I do?

  • Ideally you have a personal financial advisor or an advisor through your retirement plan who aligns with your best interest, Registered Investment Advisor (RIA). It’s worth asking if your advisor is a “fee only” fiduciary who by law is required to act in your best interest.

 

Human Investing is one of many companies who act as a fiduciary to clients and plan participants. Note: that our official stance on receiving advice from a non-professional family member is not a best practice. However, if your Uncle Larry has given you advice and you would like a second opinion, we would love to help you. Please don’t hesitate to email or call!

Call: 503.905.3100

Email: andrew@humaninvesting.com

 

 
 

Related Articles